Indiscriminate Antibiotic Use in Animals
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
October 19, 2001

Fears about anthrax have frightened some Americans into obtaining and taking antibiotics even though there is no reason to believe they have been exposed to anthrax bacteria. But the nation's livestock industry uses antibiotics even more indiscriminately; the drugs are regularly given in feed to livestock, whether sick or not, a practice that has worrisome implications for human health.

The antibiotics have been put in U.S. animal feed for decades to speed growth and prevent illness; this practice, controversial in America and elsewhere, has been severely limited in the European Union. In accordance with the EU's position, the American Medical Association recently began a sorely needed campaign to encourage the federal government to restrict the indiscriminate use of antibiotics in livestock. The AMA fears that the inappropriate use of these drugs in animals and humans is contributing to the growing problem of antibiotic-resistant bacteria.

Three studies published Thursday in the New England Journal of Medicine make the AMA's effort more urgent. One study shows a high incidence of antibiotic-resistant salmonella in ground meat obtained at a supermarket. The second suggests that the effectiveness of a powerful, recently approved human antibiotic has been compromised by the longtime use of a similar drug in animals. The third shows that antibiotic-resistant bacteria found in chicken parts and slaughtered pigs can remain at least two weeks in the intestinal tract of humans.

A guest editorial in the New England Journal properly calls the studies the "smoking gun" linking the use of antibiotics in animal production with antibiotic resistance in humans.

David Wallinga, director of the Antibiotic Resistance Project at the Minneapolis-based Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy, points out that seven of the 17 antibiotics commonly given to livestock to induce growth are either identical or nearly identical to antibiotics given to humans. These include penicillin and amoxicillin - both of which can be used to combat anthrax infection - tetracycline and erythromycin.

Even more disturbing, one study has found that 70% of antibiotics produced in this country are given to healthy pigs, cows and poultry, Wallinga notes. That is a gross and dangerous misuse of these vitally important drugs. It needs to stop, or at least be severely curtailed, in the interest of public health.


Back to Main Index Page